I’m a small town girl, so I can’t live without ten different comfortable hoodies in my closet. I ordered the best options from Amazon, and here's my hands-on ranking.
FYI, prices and ratings are accurate as of time of writing.
1. Carhartt - Relaxed-Fit Graphic Sweatshirt
Highlight: Great fit (and really cool signature logo on the sleeve).
Helpful review: Love this hoodie! I’m a small gal at 5’3’’ but it looks nice on me and has held up through multiple washes and countless wears outside. So nice to have a good hoodie that keeps me warm, even in strong winds. I really did buy it once I saw that and wasn’t disappointed. It’s really very high quality and works great for me. I’m a petite woman, as mentioned above, and my small size was good. — Laura Taylor
Get it from Amazon now: $54.99 & FREE Returns
2. The North Face - Plus-Size Pullover Hoodie
Highlight: Extra-long sleeves.
Helpful review: Can report that these hoodies work for both genders and all different kinds of bodies. I got one for myself and one for my son a few years ago, and both have lasted this long without any issues. He is sporty with a thin build and wears an M without problems. I’m a bit bigger and usually don’t feel confident in sweatshirts, but I really like this hoodie. It’s comfortable and looks good on me. No complaints from either of us. Will be wearing these hoodies for hopefully even more years! — Eva Moore
Get it from Amazon now: $60.00 & FREE Returns
3. Columbia - Trek Oversized Hoodie
Highlight: 100% Cotton.
Helpful review: These hoodies are pretty roomy, especially if you’re a woman. You may want to consider sizing down. I’m usually an L or even XL, but I went for an L on this hoodie and it looks really good. I wear it both around the house and outside and love how I look in it. I got another one in brown. They’re on constant rotation in the Nebraska cold. Thanks, Colombia. I love both hoodies. They’re thick enough to be comfortable and warm, but not so thick that they’re bulky and annoying. — Margaret Campbell
Get it from Amazon now: $54.00 & FREE Returns
4. Victoria's Secret - PINK Fleece Campus Hoodie
Highlight: Relaxed-fit is perfect for all-day wear.
Helpful review: Wasn’t sure whether to get this hoodie or not. Bought one for my granddaughter. It’s great! She has a size Small. You can really tell that it’s made in America, which was surprising. However, if you order now, the current batch is not made here... Disappointing!! It’s also surprisingly tough. If you’re wondering whether to go for this or not, just do it! I live in Minnesota and need something warm, and this definitely fits the bill without breaking the bank. Has held up for a few months and many washes. It’s really very very high quality. — Liz J. Clark
Get it from Amazon now: $52.95 & FREE Returns
5. Aelfric Eden - Pink Star Unisex Hoodie
Highlight: Really cool look with jeans and sneakers.
Helpful review: I can’t recommend this hoodie enough. Like everything else Aelfric Eden makes. But this hoodie might even be better than what I’ve come to expect from them. It’s great for those cold days, and not too bulky for warm days. After I got this one for myself, I got one for my sister and another for my daughter. I loved the designs so I got them each one. They both look great in them! Fits perfectly and was delivered quickly. No issues. Love it. What can I say? They look good and are comfy, soft, and affordable. If I buy another for myself, I’ll go for the pale-blue one. I love it! — Ruby Hall
Get it from Amazon now: $67.95 & FREE Returns
6. Ariat - Hooded Sweatshirt
Highlight: Will keep you warm in cold weather.
Helpful review: If you’re in the Northeast or anywhere else that gets really cold, you need this hoodie. Seriously, it’s comfy, durable, and warm. Wear it inside, outside, whatever. You can wash it without it shrinking too. My whole family loves this brand. Ariat also have really hot cowboy boots. Anyway, this hoodie is also a great gift. I bought one for my mom without knowing if she would like it or not. She loves it! So if you’re not sure what to get for one of your family members, you’ll have success with one of these hoodies. I guarantee you won’t regret this purchase. — Ellen Cook
Get it from Amazon now: $44.95 & FREE Returns